Labor’s New Trust Tax Will Hit Family Businesses

Labor’s proposed changes to discretionary trusts could force thousands of family businesses to restructure, seek expensive advice or face higher tax bills.

TRANSCRIPT:

Mr REBELLO (McPherson) (21:37): There’s something deeply wrong when an Australian family can spend years building a business, employing people and meeting their obligations, only to find out that the government wants to change the arrangements under which they have operated and tax their earnings away. That’s what these bills—the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026, the Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026 and the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026—will mean for many small and family businesses. Make no mistake: the coalition will oppose all of these bills.

During my first speech in this place, I talked about growing up in a family where both my parents took on extra work to get ahead. Dad was an electrician and a refrigeration mechanic. Alongside their jobs, my parents put money and a great deal of their own time into property and small business. I remember those weekends that were spent on renovations and helping the family with their business. That was how we got ahead. My parents expected to work for reward, and they expected the same of me. When their efforts paid off, they were proud of what they had been able to do for our family. I want every Australian to have that same opportunity. That experience is hardly unusual in the community that I represent. The southern Gold Coast has been built by people who are prepared to take a chance on themselves. Many began with very little, but over time they built businesses that now provide an income for other families as well as their own.

I think the Treasurer should spend a little more time considering what this legislation asks of those business owners and what he wants to take away from them. If a customer does not pay an invoice, the wages still have to be paid on time. If a job falls through, the business has to find the next one. The government doesn’t front up and help out when those figures don’t balance. The small business has to make it work. But now this government wants to show up only to rip money out of their pockets. Those opposite have decided that hundreds of thousands of businesses must now reconsider how they operate, just because the Treasurer wants more revenue to fuel a spending addiction.

A family may have set up a trust years ago on advice from their accountant or solicitor to protect their assets or to make provision for the children who will eventually take over. Now in a discretionary trust, the trustee decides how income shared amongst the beneficiaries, subject to the trust deed, and there are perfectly legitimate reasons for why a family would want that level of flexibility. The Treasurer acknowledged those legitimate purposes in his own second reading speech. Trust income is generally already taxed in the hands of beneficiaries. The suggestion that having a trust means paying no tax is simply wrong and misleading.

Under these bills from 1 July 2028, affected trustees will pay a minimum of 30 per cent tax on the trust’s taxable income, subject to the exclusions in the legislation. Individual beneficiaries will receive a non-refundable offset for the trustee’s tax. Corporate beneficiaries will not. Treasury estimates that around 350,000 active small businesses operate through discretionary trusts. It expects around 130,000 of those to require substantial advice about restructuring or making an election under those new arrangements. The government tells us that most Australians do not receive trust income as though that’s supposed to resolve the concerns of everyone who does.

We know in this place that a law is not a good law simply because it applies to a minority. The people affected are entitled to have its consequences properly considered. Now, I’m not suggesting that people should not meet their tax obligations, but, where arrangements do breach the law, the tax office should act, and they have the ability to do so through the existing framework of legislation. But the government also has an obligation to explain why its reckless spending spree should impose these costs on businesses, businesses that have operated lawfully for many years.

The Treasurer’s answer when those businesses object is that they have options. So let’s look at those options. A business can remain under its existing arrangements and face the new minimum tax. It can restructure or an eligible trust can elect to make distributions in fixed proportions to nominated beneficiaries. Restructuring might sound straightforward to a minister reading a brief, but for a business owner it can involve revisiting finance, licences, insurance and contracts, as well as paying for legal and accounting advice. The costs involved in this do not appear out of nowhere. It’s a significant cost to the business, and it has to come out of somewhere. The Commonwealth’s proposed rollover relief does not in and of itself remove state and territory stamp duty. A business moving assets into a company can still face a substantial bill. The Treasurer cannot announce relief from one tax and pretend that he’s also dealt with the whole cost of that change.

The choice is also far more restrictive than the government’s language currently suggests. Eligible existing trusts get an opportunity in 2028 to 2029 to nominate beneficiaries and their respective shares. To retain the exemption, distributions must continue to meet those requirements. Now, there are limited provisions for death and relationship breakdown. But if you choose to have another child or to remarry, you can’t simply update the nominated beneficiaries to include them. A couple could make this election while their children are still at school, but, 20 years later, one of those children might be running the business or another might have moved away. Why should the proportions that they settled on in 2028 still determine whether they qualify for the exemption? Families can’t know all of that in advance. The Treasurer should understand that. Departing from the prescribed distributions can bring significant and severe tax consequences and the loss of the exemption in future years subject to limited relief. That is a considerable price to pay and to attach to the flexibility that families have previously relied on.

There’s a further problem where a company receives income from a discretionary trust. Because corporate beneficiaries do not receive the minimum tax offset, the income can be taxed at the trust level and again at the company level. In some arrangements, the combined tax can reach as high as 60 per cent. That’s not the rate that every trust will pay, but it’s a consequence that the government has chosen to allow, and it matters to those businesses who are using both trusts and companies together. Telling those businesses to rearrange their affairs does not answer the concern. It confirms that they must change what they’re doing and that they must bear the cost to avoid the consequences of the Treasurer’s legislation.

These costs have particular significance for housing. Master Builders examined what the proposed changes would mean for a family that has a building business and is earning $400,000 in taxable income. According to the modelling that was released in August, changing the business structure could cost the owners anywhere from $82,000 to $175,000. It also found that a business of that size could see its tax bill rise by as much as 70 per cent. That’s a significant increase in anyone’s tax bill and comes as a serious warning from the people who represent the businesses we need to build more homes. On the Gold Coast, housing affordability affects the decisions that young people make about their future. It affects whether they can remain near their families, whether they can take a job locally and whether they can begin to build some financial security. We need more homes and we need businesses capable of building them. If a builder has to commit substantial funds to restructuring, those funds are unavailable for equipment, staff or the next project. If operating costs continue to rise, it puts upward pressure on the price of construction, and, if the return no longer justifies the risk, some projects will, quite frankly, just not proceed.

Those opposite cannot keep promising more housing as they continually make it harder and more expensive for the businesses expected to deliver it. They also can’t claim to be reducing the burden on small business while introducing a measure with compliance costs of this scale. Treasury puts the average annual regulatory cost at approximately $141 million over 10 years. The total over the decade includes $939 million in one-off implementation costs. These costs will all come before the additional tax itself. It’s the cost of understanding the change, obtaining advice and putting new arrangements in place, and the cost of all of this will be shouldered by the businesses. For a small business, the hours spent doing that have to come from somewhere. Often, they come after the working day, or before, when the owners are already doing the accounts or preparing for the day ahead. Members opposite should give that time the same consideration that they give to a department’s time when it asks for more resources to implement a policy.

The process has done little to give business owners confidence. There were 23 days for public consultation in July—immediately after the end of the financial year, when businesses, as we all know, have a lot going on—followed by 15 days on the exposure drafts in September. The Senate inquiry is not due to report until 13 November. Yet this government wants to ram the legislation through the House tomorrow before reading the inquiry’s report. The minimum tax does not begin until July 2028. There’s time to examine the consequences properly. There’s time to hear from the accountants who’ll have to explain these rules and the business owners who’ll have to live with them. The government should use that time effectively to closely examine the impact of the laws. But, instead, important aspects of this framework remain dependent on further rules. Businesses are expected to plan significant changes without the complete arrangements before them. As someone who worked in law before entering this place, I understand why certainty matters when people are making long-term commitments. Parliament should be reducing avoidable uncertainty, because, when it’s parliament’s own decisions that are creating it, there is something wrong.

That brings me to the other measures in the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026. The coalition supports schedule 6, which provides transitional relief where the move to payday super affects an individual’s concessional contributions cap. Workers should not be disadvantaged simply because the timing of their employer’s payments changes. We don’t oppose schedules 4 and 5, which pick up some corrections to the government’s capital gains tax and negative gearing changes, but that doesn’t mean by any stretch of the imagination that we endorse the underlying tax changes or believe that the corrections go far enough. Take the treatment of granny flats under the ‘new home’ definition. A family buys an established investment property after budget night and builds a self-contained granny flat out the back, something a lot of people might want to do. Someone can now live there who could not have lived there before. But unless that granny flat has its own title, it does not count as a new dwelling for the purposes of these rules. In an established suburb, there may be very little vacant land left to build on. Adding a granny flat to an existing block is one way to get another home built. It’s difficult to see why a government that, on the one hand, says it wants more housing would, on the other hand, leave that out.

We’re seeking to separate schedules 4 to 6 from the trust tax provisions so that this House can consider them on their merits. There’s no good reason a worker’s transitional superannuation relief should depend on accepting this new tax on trusts. There’s a broader difference in approach here. Those opposite speak as though every problem in the budget creates a fresh entitlement to Australians’ earnings. They expect families to adjust, businesses to restructure and taxpayers to find the money, while they treat restraint in government as an unreasonable demand. I believe government should be held to the same expectation of responsibility as that we place on the people we represent.

This week the coalition set out $31 billion in on-budget savings over the four years from 2028-29. We’ve put forward decisions to reduce waste and corporate welfare, along with our tax back guarantee to index income tax brackets. Australians are entitled to expect us to do the work before asking them for more. We’re also consulting on a small-business act, which will include a right to be heard, because the consequences for small business should be considered before government and regulators act.

So on these bills our position is clear: we oppose the trust tax; we are seeking to split the legislation; and if the government refuses to withdraw the tax, we’re calling for commencement to be delayed by 12 months to allow proper consultation—and, make no mistake, if this becomes law, a coalition government will axe this toxic new tax. I want the next generation of Australians to have the confidence to start a business and the opportunity to make it succeed. I want them to believe that years of effort will leave their families better off. The Treasurer should axe this tax and listen to the businesses affected. If he will not, he should expect us to oppose it here and campaign for its repeal.